I read a book this last weekend that I really enjoyed, until the last line.
Ug.
There was so much conflict, so much struggle, so much longing and hope for something better. There were epic battles, HUGE sacrifices, and pain... And all of that would have been worth it, except for that darn last line.
I think about that sometimes, about life and goals and how we strive and hope for an ultimate outcome. We may even fight and sacrifice for that outcome, but it all comes down to that last line. Do we eventually give up? Do we hold strong until the very end?
Last week, Jay Noel shared SHADOW WARRIOR with us, along with two truths and one lie. Those who guessed the lie correctly were entered into a random drawing for the chance to win one of his ebooks.
Jay's game:
1. Jay had a near-death experience in his 20's.
2. His biggest fear is being poked in the eye.
3. He went skydiving on his 40th birthday.
And the lie is:
...DRUM ROLL...
Congrats Diane!
MARY PAX ~ M. Pax is author of the series, The Backworlds, The Rifters, and has other novels and several short stories published. Fantasy, science fiction, and the weird beckons to her, and she blames Oregon for that, a source of endless inspiration. She docents at Pine Mountain Observatory in the summers, teaching the public about the stars and the galaxy. A Bachelors of Science in Journalism, she had former lives in marketing and television before settling down to write.
Ug.
There was so much conflict, so much struggle, so much longing and hope for something better. There were epic battles, HUGE sacrifices, and pain... And all of that would have been worth it, except for that darn last line.
I think about that sometimes, about life and goals and how we strive and hope for an ultimate outcome. We may even fight and sacrifice for that outcome, but it all comes down to that last line. Do we eventually give up? Do we hold strong until the very end?
Source |
POST AMENDED: At the request of several readers, I will share that the last line was a cliff hanger. Yes, cliffhanger. I know some of us feel that's okay, and sometimes it is...but not in the very last sentence of the book. You have to give the reader some warning. And seriously, if you're going to kill half (or more) of the cast to accomplish something, don't leave your readers feeling like all the victory was stolen by the last line. Yes, I said STOLEN. *sigh* Rant over.
Ready to guess the lie and win a book?
Jay's game:
2. His biggest fear is being poked in the eye.
3. He went skydiving on his 40th birthday.
#3. Jay did not go skydiving for his 40th birthday.
Way to guess those of you who got it right! And the winner is:
...DRUM ROLL...
Congrats Diane!
And now to today's feature:
A junction between the worlds erupts.
The Gold Rush trickles to a fool’s quest and a string of stagecoach heists. In 1888, Earl Blacke makes a new start to become a better man. He escapes into the mountains, heading north. In the wilds of Oregon, a rift inside an ancient volcano opens, sending him into the future, into the present day. It also shaves thirty years off his age, thirty years to live over and atone for what he’s done.
Starting over is hard to do. In current day New York City, Daelin Long’s dream job at a publishing house goes the way of the dinosaurs her sister chases. With no money and nowhere else to go, Daelin accepts the librarian position in her sister’s dinky town in the middle of Oregon. Nestled inside ancient volcanic peaks, the town of Settler holds onto many secrets. Residents roam the streets with weirdly fashioned devices, and odd lights pulse in the night skies. People whisper of a phantom outlaw and start dying, murdered and missing their heads. Worse, Daelin’s sister is missing, and Daelin doesn’t know who to trust.
Earl knows more than he’s saying. He shares a notorious history with the phantom, one he’ll see remains buried. Keeping Daelin’s sister’s secrets is his only chance at redemption, and the only way to keep this world safe.
The Gold Rush trickles to a fool’s quest and a string of stagecoach heists. In 1888, Earl Blacke makes a new start to become a better man. He escapes into the mountains, heading north. In the wilds of Oregon, a rift inside an ancient volcano opens, sending him into the future, into the present day. It also shaves thirty years off his age, thirty years to live over and atone for what he’s done.
Starting over is hard to do. In current day New York City, Daelin Long’s dream job at a publishing house goes the way of the dinosaurs her sister chases. With no money and nowhere else to go, Daelin accepts the librarian position in her sister’s dinky town in the middle of Oregon. Nestled inside ancient volcanic peaks, the town of Settler holds onto many secrets. Residents roam the streets with weirdly fashioned devices, and odd lights pulse in the night skies. People whisper of a phantom outlaw and start dying, murdered and missing their heads. Worse, Daelin’s sister is missing, and Daelin doesn’t know who to trust.
Earl knows more than he’s saying. He shares a notorious history with the phantom, one he’ll see remains buried. Keeping Daelin’s sister’s secrets is his only chance at redemption, and the only way to keep this world safe.
You might stumble across Mary while on a picnic out in the wilds of Oregon or at a lunch gathering with her writer gal pals, munching on brie.
Mary gave me two truths and one lie to test your "lie detector" skills. Those who figure out the lie will go into my magic hat for the chance to win BOTH eBook's: The Rifters, and The Initiate--before release. How awesome is that?
You have until Tuesday, August 26th, at 1 p.m. EDT to guess--and be sure to come back for the answer on August 27th.
TRUTH OR LIE
1. Mary stood behind Kurt Vonnegut once in line at a newstand. They spoke for hours in the gardens of Dag Hammerskjold smoking Shermans.
2. She went on a ghost hunt in the Caribbean. On Nevis there’s a tale about a woeful bride who had a fateful wedding day.
3. On the first date with her husband unit, she hit his car. She was pretty sure there’d be no second date. Fooled her!
2. She went on a ghost hunt in the Caribbean. On Nevis there’s a tale about a woeful bride who had a fateful wedding day.
3. On the first date with her husband unit, she hit his car. She was pretty sure there’d be no second date. Fooled her!
Which is the lie? Do you have a secret goal you're pushing toward? Have you ever given up on something and then wished you hadn't? What do you think of time rifts?
I'll try not to mess up my last line.
ReplyDeleteWow, Mary - those are tough! I'm going to say the second one.
Most important line of the entire book, right?
DeleteI'm kind of dying to know what that last line was! I hope my last line is good...I think it is anyway. I've actually thought of getting it tattooed somewhere, but I have no actual desire to get a tattoo...maybe a nice embroidered pillow...
ReplyDeleteLOL! I love that--but I'm right there with you, no tattoos. Maybe a nice framed all hanging, eh?
DeleteAnd now I'm curious about what the last line was, and how one line could ruin an entire book. O_o The only things I can think of right now are revealing it was all a dream, or having someone's character utterly and thoroughly derailed with a single sentence. Oi.
ReplyDeleteIt happens, right? I mean, what was up with Katnis in Hunger Games #3. Yeah, I just spent the last couple years of my life battling to survive in an arena, but hey, I'm all for another hunger games! Ug. ;)
DeleteWow, that really sucks about that last line! Don't think I've ever had a book ruined for me because of a single line before, but a last chapter did ruin an entire 12-book series for me once, so...I feel your pain!
ReplyDeleteIt's the worst, right? After investing your time and efforts...
DeleteYeah, I'm wondering what that line is, too. "And then she woke up. Phew, it was all a dream!" ~ That was the end of many, many fifth grade stories I read in my 25 year career. MANY!
ReplyDeleteLOL. I know. Middle graders are so creative. =)
DeleteYour Gold Rush stories sound great! I have no idea which one is your lie. My total guess is #1.
ReplyDeleteHi, Crystal :)
Hi, Carol. =D
DeleteI would be disappointed if I was enjoying a book and the last line ruined it... (Maybe that is why I read the end of a book before I actually read the book). [I know... I'm different :-)]
ReplyDeleteHah! You're one of those cheaters... *squinty eye* Okay, I admit I've peeked at the end on a couple books, but just because I had a sneaking suspicion I was going to be disappointed, and knowing for sure in advance makes the blow easier.
DeleteIt's sad when the end of a book (or even just the last line) disappoints.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to guess #1 as the lie.
Yeah... I mean, I'm all for a dose of reality, but I want to be happy about the ending too.
DeleteThat last line is so important!
ReplyDeleteHi, Mary. I'm going to guess #1 is the lie.
Tremendously!
DeleteHa, I rewrote my last chapter of my novella because beta-readers hated my last line. Well, not everyone. There were a few who appreciated my twisted sense of humor. But alas, the majority want happy endings.
ReplyDeleteI say the lie is #2.
It's true, and as authors who hope to make money, we better give them what they want, right? (Yes, I'm a total sell out.)
DeleteI don't quit things which I think makes me stubborn. At least so my husband says. I love time rift ideas and I believe M. Pax lied in #1.
ReplyDeleteI say it makes you determined, and all the better for it. =)
DeleteI have felt that too - when reading a book that has an ending that disappoints. in particular, The Tortilla Curtain comes to mind. Sheesh, a depressing and disappointing book!
ReplyDeleteI hate depressing books. Seriously. There's a reason I cling to the genres I read. =)
DeleteGood post :)
ReplyDeleteThanks!
DeleteI've felt that way after reading certain books, too, so I try really hard to make my last line good.
ReplyDeleteRight? I'm totally there with you.
DeleteCongrats, Diane! :)
ReplyDeleteEndings are important. They can really make a difference on if I like a book or movie or play or not. Also, on whether we succeed or not. ^_^
Ooh, I hope number 3 is true! Lol! I'm going with #1 today.
It's true. That final impression is what the reader will take with them long afterward. It better be epic. =)
DeleteThe last line needs to be as great as the first - hate it when the ending leaves you thinking, well so what!
ReplyDeleteI'm gonna say #1 is the lie.
I think it needs to be better.
DeleteNow I'm curious as to what the last line is that ruins everything. Was it all a dream? That would do it. Thanks for the feature today, Crystal.
ReplyDeleteNo, no dream, but almost as bad. =)
DeleteGlad to have you, Mary.
I'm going to go with her hitting the hubs with her car. Mary's covers look awesome!!
ReplyDeleteThey do, right?
DeleteI think #3 is the lie! I have given up on a few things in my life but rarely regret them!
ReplyDeleteThere are times we have to abandon something before it kills us, eh?
DeleteI was helping someone once with a draft review and he ended it like this..."and he told his mother and she set things right, but thats a tale for another day..." I told him that if he ever tried to publish his book like that I would disown him, and other violent threats. 'bad endings" is just lazy writing
ReplyDeleteLOL. Too true. I'm reminded of the way Stephen King ended is Dark Tower series. Lazy writing sucks.
DeleteI'm guessing #3 is the lie. But if it's true, that's a heck of a way to begin a relationship! I like your quote at the beginning.
ReplyDeleteI know! It's story worthy, eh?
DeleteWhat a great reminder that the last line is just as important as the first!
ReplyDeleteI say the lie is #1!
It totally is.
DeleteBut now I really want to know what that last line was. Was it a cliffhanger that means you have to read the next book? Did it ruin a characterization for you? If authors tick me off, it's usually well before the last page. (I still haven't forgiven one of my fav authors for killing one of his main characters.)
ReplyDeleteYeah... I would share it too, but I don't want to flame the book or author. I'm sure there are tonz of people who love her book, regardless.
DeleteI know what you mean about not forgiving an author. It wasn't the characterization, it totally had to do with the plot.
One line ruined the whole book? That's actually quite impressive.
ReplyDeleteIt's really not fair, you know, to talk about something like that without disclosing.
I know, right? Takes talent...or stupidity. =)
DeleteYeah... I don't want to harm the author or their work in any way. I know other people love it, and who am I to be an author killer?
What a tease you are! Even if you don't feel like posting the last line and identifying the book, as least you could tell us what the sin was. I mean, some of us are still learning and I want to make sure I never make the same mistake. Oh please, please....
ReplyDeleteWell, as long as your last line doesn't betray the happy ending by throwing it on its ear, you should be good to go.
DeleteI'm curious about the last line now. I haven't read a book where that happened to me. Normally, the last line makes me want more.
ReplyDeleteMe too, but this one didn't. After a gut-wrenching book, I was very glad to be at the end and find a happily ever after...NOT. It was a happily ever after...until the last sentence. Do you know how robbed I feel?
DeleteI'm not a fan of cliffhanger last sentences, either. After investing so much time reading a book, it feels like a rip-off if the ending isn't really an ending, and nothing is resolved.
ReplyDeleteHmmm, I'll guess that #1 is the fib. (Although it'd be totally cool if it isn't.)
AGREED. The author needs to resolve the plot. If they want to leave something hanging, fine, but don't make it the major issue of the entire book, right?
DeleteI just read what I thought was the last book in a trilogy only to have that happen! I feel lied to and strung along for my money because now if I want to get any resolution...I have to buy book four. Bleh!
ReplyDeleteRaquel Byrnes
Ug. I know! I read one series I hated, but I HAD to get through the entire thing. I was so happy when I got to book three, and soooo peeved when the series stretched into 5 novels. Gag.
DeleteOh sheesh, I'm one of those gal pals that eats Brie with Mary and I'm still totally guessing about her lie. It feels like there is a kernel of truth in each answer, so which has the fib hidden within? I'm guessing 2.
ReplyDeleteAs one who has been pelted by tomatoes (or more accurately, Kindles) over her cliffhanger ending, I'm saying, "Dang it! Sometimes it just needs to be that way." However, like Raquel, I too have read what I thought was the last book in a series only to find out there is more. That really screws with your psyche.
It's true, sometimes they do, but it has to be done right. There has to be enough resolution. I'm waiting to dive into your series until the 3rd book is out. =)
DeleteDang. I was sure I'd guessed Joel's lie. I'm going to try again with Mary and say, #1's the lie. But I'm really hoping it happened. I mean Kurt V!
ReplyDeleteGuess I'll have to read that book to find out what the last line was about. It must have been some line to stir you up like this.
That or I'm easily frustrated by books. It could be either one. ;)
DeleteI have friends from Nevis, and I'm pretty sure I would have heard that story if it existed. So I'm guessing #2. I love that Lance Armstrong quote btw.
ReplyDeleteWow. It's a small world! How cool.
Delete#1 seems like the obvious lie, but almost too obvious . . . so I'm going with #2. As for cliffhangers, I'm not a fan. If it's a series, of course I want to be left with wanting more, but I get disappointed with total cliffhangers too. Now I do LOVE surprise endings. The ones I never saw coming are the ones I remember for years after I've finished the book.
ReplyDeleteYes, surprise endings are epic, but not in the last sentence. No one wants that abrupt a surprise.
DeleteOkay, I must admit that I am seriously curious what book this was :) Anyhow, guessing #1 is the lie!
ReplyDeleteEmail me if you really want to know. It was totally a book my daughter picked up and then I had to read it before her to make sure it was appropriate for a 9 year old. (It wasn't, btw.)
DeleteI'm curious about what book you were reading too! As for the lie, I think it's #1. If it isn't, I'm jealous.
ReplyDeleteI know, I'm such a tease. Maybe I'll have to do a follow up post...once I've read book 2 and been vindicated or further enraged.
DeleteI won't read a book if it has a cliffhanger ending. When it comes as a surprise, I'm too annoyed, lol
ReplyDelete#1 is the lie
Me too. It totally didn't sound like it was going to be a cliffhanger.
DeleteI'm definitely don't like cliffhanger endings, especially since the time between books being published is so freakin' long. I've gotten to the point that I won't start a series until it's finished because it's just too frustrating for me.
ReplyDeleteUsually I'm that same way, but I had no indication it was going to be part of a series. Ug.
DeleteHi Crystal. I hate it when the end of a book disappoints. I feel like throwing it across the room. That's the good thing about print books. No way am I going to throw my Kindle across the room. Cliffhangers are good at chapter endings, but not book endings unless you already have the next in the series out.
ReplyDeleteCongrats to M Pax.
I say #2 is the lie.
Denise
LOL! I'm going to have to remember that: only buy paper so you can abuse the book if disappointed. ;)
DeleteI don't like cliffhangers. I understand why that last line would bother you.
ReplyDeleteLove,
Janie
Yuppers. They're mean, right?
DeleteI've seen the last episode of a TV show ruining the whole thing before. Although, in those cases, I pretend that episode never happened. But I've read books that the ending just ruined the whole book. So frustrating.
ReplyDeleteAs for the lie...#2...
Um, yeah MERLIN. (Stupid, stupid, stupid.)
DeleteI wont say the ending ruined the book...or at least it might not have for most people, but it did for me.
There was no indication that it would end in a cliffhanger until the last line. That's an outrage! And gosh I'm not sure what's the life. 1 maybe, but I hope it's true
ReplyDeleteI KNOW. There should have been some forewarning, right?
DeleteI'm going to guess the lie is number 2...
ReplyDeleteI have The Backworlds waiting for me in my Kindle and will most likely be adding The Rifters to my TBR list as well=)
If I can't relate to the ending of a book or it just doesn't make sense, it can be very frustrating. Especially since we allowed ourselves to get so lost within the author's world and then BAM, nada. Ah well, it's a good thing there are an infinite amount of amazing stories out there to keep our hopes afloat.
Yeah, the ending really does make it or break it, right?
DeleteI have to say I like knowing beforehand that the book I'm reading is part of a series. I'd be pissed, too, if it came as a huge surprise like that. As for M. Pax, I'm going to guess that #1 is the lie.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. It stinks to be surprised that way.
DeleteI am NOT a fan of cliffhangers. I abandoned 1 or 2 YA series because book 1 didn't resolve enough because of a cliffhanger. I wonder which book....
ReplyDeleteI hope Mary's truth is the Kurt one. That would be so cool!
=) I know, I'm a tease.
DeleteI don't mind a small cliffhanger or something more to come, but NO, not something that makes you throw the book at the cat or dog or out the window. Mary's books look amazing! I'm guessing #1 is the lie. I can believe standing in line but chatting for hours...hmm.
ReplyDeleteYeah... Not all twists are good ones, eh?
DeleteWoot woot! I won! :D
ReplyDeleteI do not like cliff hangers unless they are at the end of a chapter. It makes me want to turn the page and read more. I would hate it at the end of a book. Feels too much like you're being duped into buying the next book. Not good!
Agreed. No one wants to be duped.
DeleteOh, and I think #1 is a lie! :)
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, YAY for Mary's Rifters!
ReplyDeleteAs for novel endings, call me sentimental, but I tend to like endings with SOME rays of hope/love/creative solutions. I don't mind a character being bumped off but for heavens sake, don't kill 'em all, or snuff out all the glowing embers. And that goes for a series as well. Give me a partial cliffhanger or leave some threads untied but don't leave me dangling from one thin branch. OK, rant over now.
I know. There has to be a balance for all the death and mayhem, right?
DeleteI nicked a guy's new car on our first date - hit the car door against a parking meter. I was pretty sure I wouldn't have a second date. I was right. Still, I believe Mary's #3. When it's meant to be, a nice guy will forgive his car being smashed. That said, I'll go with #1 as the lie. I'm doubtful such a famous author is capable of extensive face-to-face discourse.
ReplyDeleteLOL. Robyn, he just wasn't the right guy then.
DeleteI'll go with lie #3. I like cliffhangers on TV shows, but in a book, hmmm....
ReplyDeleteYeah...there's just too my air time between them.
DeleteLeaving on a cliffhanger like that feels to me like a breach of trust between author and reader. I'd be mad too! Open story questions, things that clearly lead to more to come, OK, but by the end of a book I think the reader has earned some sort of resolution even if it's clearly not truly the end.
ReplyDeleteYeah, and if you're going to leave a breach, things to be answered later, at least don't do it in the last sentence.
DeleteWhen you invest so much time reading a book, it's such a letdown to be left hanging, so I feel your pain Crystal. I'm horrible at this game, but #1 sounds too good to be true. Congrats to Mary!
ReplyDeleteJulie
You totally got it! So much for being horrible at the game. =)
DeleteI'm guilty of cliff-hangers. Don't shoot! :(
ReplyDeleteMary is one of the most hardworking writers I know! I say the lie is number two! :) Why? No idea, but it's as good as any and I would believe anything possible with Mary. ;)
shahwharton.com
Won't shoot--as long as you don't write them into the last sentence.
DeleteI think number one is the lie. :)
ReplyDeleteI think you're right. =)
Deletei can't stand when a book has a bad last line and if it's cliffhangers, then ooh man!
ReplyDeleteI know, right?!
DeleteWell now I'm totally questioning my last line! And gosh you're a tease, you know we all wanna know now, right? Right LOL
ReplyDeleteI'm going with #2 as the lie!
Yeah, I know. I'm shameful.
DeleteI agree with you 100%; however, I've been learning that many agents and editors actually push writers to end their story on a cliffhanger. I know, I know (shakes my head). So much for resolution;)
ReplyDeleteSome do, and I think it's a wise tactic, but not on a first book.
DeleteOkay. Okay. Now I am terribly piqued by this book! It sounds like it was darn good, but just...gah! Cliffhangers. I always hate that for the final season premiers of my favorite TV shows. :( But ooooh they're so darn good.
ReplyDeleteYeah, this wasn't in a good way. I was actually really looking forward to the book being over...only to have it not be.
DeleteI think #1 is the lie. I wish M Pax the best of luck. Love her covers. :) Can't wait to read them.
ReplyDeleteI do not like when books end with a cliffhanger. I need to have the main plot points resolved by the end of the book, even if it is part of a series. :)
~Jess
Agreed. There can be other things hanging, but not MAIN plot points.
DeleteThat is SO frustrating when you devote all this time to a great story and then it leaves you unsatisfied!
ReplyDeleteI KNOW!
DeleteOh! I got Jay's quiz wrong!!! Blast!!!
ReplyDeleteAnd LOL… one of my books totally has a cliff hanger ending… ha. Maybe I should re think that… ;-)
LOL. If it's the second book in the series, I say leave it. Otherwise...
DeleteNow I'm really curious what book made you so angry. I do love cliffhanger endings usually or characters that fight to get nothing in return, because it often mimics life.
ReplyDeleteI guess that's true, but at least we learn a lesson from it and usually find a way to validate the torture. 3 dead main characters later... There's no way to truly validate that.
DeleteHi Crystal .. congratulations to Diane; as far as Mary is concerned .. her book premise sounds fascinating ... and the lie - I think it just might be #3 ...
ReplyDeleteBut - what was that line? When something irritates us, or upsets us in a book - it really rankles for ever doesn't it ... let us know!!! Cheers Hilary
LOL. I'm sure the final line wouldn't bother everyone. It just totally hit me wrong.
DeleteUGH! That is frustrating. Even in a series, each book should have closure. You give readers a reason to move on to book 2, but you close book 1 up or they just get angry!!!
ReplyDeleteAgreed.
DeleteUh oh. Now I'm going to be afraid to finish the book I'm reading. If it's bad, I'll mark it out and pretend it didn't happen!
ReplyDeleteI KNOW. I totally should, right? (Except it's a library book.)
DeleteYeep, that's disappointing about the last line. Sorry to hear it. Hope your next read doesn't leave you hanging like that. And I'll guess number 3 is the lie :)
ReplyDeleteMy next read didn't leave me hanging. THANK YOU, TC MCKEE! =)
DeleteYeep, that's disappointing about the last line. Sorry to hear it. Hope your next read doesn't leave you hanging like that. And I'll guess number 3 is the lie :)
ReplyDeletecool happenings, as usual! sorry about that last line, i hate that!
ReplyDeleteyay for Jay and his winner, Diane!
and yay for Mary! but i have to say, number one has to be the lie - not for hours, but would be awesome!
I know, right? It would be awesome.
DeleteThe book did evoke an emotional response from it's reader so it did its job...another way of looking at it!
ReplyDeleteCongrats to Mary!
Sure, but is it a good response? I could probably flame it based on my response, but I won't. No, I won't.
DeleteCongratulations to Mary and everyone!
ReplyDeleteSeconded!
DeleteI think #1 is the lie.
ReplyDeleteCongrats to Mary.
I got Jay's wrong. So he is fearful of eye pokes.
He is. Crazy, right?
DeleteAhh, a cliffhanger. I take it there is a sequel to this novel?
ReplyDeleteMary's book sounds so cool! I'll guess the lie is #1 even though it is so crazy it is probably true.
There is a sequel...a year from now. *grumble, grumble, grumble*
DeleteHaha! I do love you Crystal. It is annoying but I always like to leave an ambiguity at the end of a story. Unless you come along and tell me to finish it properly :))
ReplyDeleteAmbiguity is acceptable. This was in-your-face blatantly lame.
DeleteThe lie is no.#1
ReplyDeleteMary is such a go-getter! A really prolific writer!
She really is.
DeleteCliffhangers bug me, especially when the sequel is a long time away from being published. The ending can make or break the book; I just finished reading a book that was otherwise pretty good but had an anticlimactic ending, which kind of ruined the rest of the story for me.
ReplyDelete